Menu. 78 Reviews (908) 221-1177 Website. This is not your typical pizza joint, but one that specializes in custom made pizzas and is an off spring of the Nicoletta Pizzeria in New York City. 107 Morristown Rd, Bernardsville, NJ 07924. We go for happy hour frequently. We also got rigatoni with really great meatballs. I wish I could give half stars 3.5-4 is how I would rate this place. Are the prices at this restaurant mid-range / moderate? As we waited for our food we watched the kitchen staff punch and slap and kick each other for the better part of the entire time we were there. Get quick answers from Nicoletta staff and past visitors. As we waited for our food we watched the kitchen staff punch and slap and kick each other for the better part of the entire time we were there. What bothers me when I have such an experience is that it is almost impossible for a kitchen to prepare a dish that was this poorly executed - and not be aware of it. NEVER AGAIN for me . Twitter. Ordered Pizza, a Nicoletta salad and a chicken parmesan. Nicoletta makes it easy. Food: Service was...great too!More. A NICOLETTA meal for 2- only $30. Nicoletta Pizzeria at 107 Morristown Rd, Bernardsville, NJ 07924 Pizza was good. See, For debit cards, select "credit" when you pay. Service excellent, simple but pleasing decor. Note: your question will be posted publicly on the Questions & Answers page. They have a large bar but we BYOB for a corkage fee on the nights they allow.. Not your neighborhood joint. Nicoletta is a new Pizzeria located between Morini Osteria Restaurant and CVS Pharmacy at the 107 Morristown Rd plaza. © 2020 Groupon, Inc. All Rights Reserved. NEVER AGAIN for me . a little more to add pepperoni, etc! Nicoletta’s signature pizzas include a variety of specialty pies such as the Calabrese, topped with thick-cut pepperoni, house made fennel sausage and red onions, or the Tartufata, with prosciutto cotto, wild mushrooms, truffle cream and mozzarella. It was presented over a pile of over seasoned spinach, was a generous portion but sadly lacking in taste and texture. Facebook. At Nicoletta Pizzeria, White and his team of chefs hand-toss pizzas like the Campanaccio, a pie featuring mushrooms, mozzarella, fennel sausage, and garlic oil. .More, I was going camping at Jockey Hollow recently and needed a quick meal before I started my camping trip. Excellent Pizza! Still they send it out anyway, hoping perhaps that it'll be accepted. The menu at Nicoletta features the same high quality, artisanal ingredients served at the original outpost of Nicoletta pizzeria in Manhattan’s East Village.